Feature Article
Fórsa grant scheme invites applications
by Niall Shanahan
 

Fórsa is inviting members to apply to its third-level grant support scheme, which gives limited financial assistance to those undertaking certified educational courses – up to third level – that will assist them in carrying out their union representative role.


Fórsa is inviting members to apply to its third-level grant support scheme, which gives limited financial assistance to those undertaking certified educational courses – up to third level – that will assist them in carrying out their union representative role.


Applicants, who must be fully paid-up Fórsa members, can only apply by completing the approved application form. They must also have the support of their own Fórsa branch.


The scheme does not cover courses designed to enhance professional or career development unless they also improve a member’s ability to act as a Fórsa rep. The closing date for applications is 5.30pm on Friday 27th September 2019.


Full details of the application requirements and available supports can be found HERE.


The approved application form is available HERE.

Articles A
Salary increases for health workers
by Bernard Harbor
 

Health workers in the HSE and ‘section 38’ organisations, including large voluntary hospitals, will see their pay increase by 1.75% from this month.


Health workers in the HSE and ‘section 38’ organisations, including large voluntary hospitals, will see their pay increase by 1.75% from this month. The increase, which takes effect from 1st September, was negotiated by Fórsa as part of the Public Service Stability Agreement (PSSA).

 

This is the second pay adjustment to be implemented this year. The pay of health staff who earn less than €30,000 a year went up by 1% in January, while those earning over €30,000 benefited from a reduced contribution to the ‘additional superannuation contribution,’ which replaced the so-called ‘pension levy’ under the PSSA.

 

There were also two increases - each worth 1% - in 2018. Next year will see a further adjustment in the additional superannuation contribution in January, and a 2% pay increase is due in October. The PSSA expires at the end of 2020.

 

The union is currently updating the pay scales on the Fórsa website.

Court adjourns disability network hearing
by Bernard Harbor
 

The Labour Court has temporarily adjourned its hearing into a dispute over clinical governance and reporting relationships in new ‘children’s disability networks’ to allow direct discussions between Fórsa and the HSE.


The Labour Court has temporarily adjourned its hearing into a dispute over clinical governance and reporting relationships in new ‘children’s disability networks’ to allow direct discussions between Fórsa and the HSE.

 

Its chair Kevin Foley offered a six-week period for direct talks after making it clear that, if asked to make a recommendation, the Court would rule that responsibility for deployment of clinical governance lies with the employer.

 

This would mean rejection of the union’s submission, which opposed the HSE’s plans to give new children’s disability network managers (CDNMs) responsibility for both clinical governance and operational line management of health and social care professionals (HSCPs) working in 86 local children’s disability networks.

 

The parties, who have so far failed to reach agreement despite three Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) sessions, now have until 22nd September to find common ground. Otherwise the court will rule.

 

Fórsa officials involved in the direct discussions, which are currently underway, believe the HSE may be willing to agree a settlement similar to that won by the union for HSCPs in an earlier tussle over clinical governance in community healthcare organisations (CHOs).

 

That compromise established nine one-year-long pilots, where HSCP heads of discipline retain responsibility for clinical governance of HSCP staff, but operational line management is the responsibility of network managers working in collaboration with the heads of discipline.

 

The agreement also brought a number of additional gains for HSCPs, including the re-establishment of the suspended manager-in-charge III posts, a practical commitment to review the career pathways for HSCPs (which is now underway), and a commitment that there would be no reduction in the number of heads of discipline.

 

The talks are continuing for the time being.

Putting the public back in public hosptials
by Diarmaid Mac a Bhaird
 

Fórsa has welcomed proposals for legislation to ensure that public hospitals are used for public patients only.


Fórsa has welcomed proposals for legislation to ensure that public hospitals are used for public patients only. The recommendation is included in a report by the independent review group established to examine private activity in public hospitals, which was published earlier this week.

 

The report makes eight recommendations aimed at developing a single-tier public hospital system as envisaged in the 2017 Sláintecare reform programme, which has cross-party support.

 

They include the introduction of legislation to ensure that public hospitals are exclusively used for the treatment of public patients, and a new consultant contract that bars private practice in public hospitals.

 

The head of Fórsa’s health division, Éamonn Donnelly, said he welcomed the report’s recommendations, noting that they are in line with the union’s submission to the review body.

 

“Implementation of the independent review body’s recommendations would be a major step towards developing a fair and egalitarian health system,” he said.

 

But he warned that legal wrangles could stall the implementation of the report’s recommendations.

 

The independent review group estimates that it would take ten years to take private work out of public hospitals, and that it would take approximately €500 million worth of private health insurance payments out of the hospital system each year.

 

Recommendations of the Report of the Independent Review Group

• Introduce legislation to ensure that public hospitals are exclusively used for the treatment of public patients from the conclusion of the ten-year Sláintecare implementation period;
• All new consultant appointments should be to a Sláintecare Consultant Contract, which allows only public activity in public hospitals;
• Restore pay to pre-October 2012 pay levels for all existing Type A contracts and new entrant Sláintecare Consultant Contracts;
• Consultants holding 2008 (or earlier) contracts under which the consultant conducts private activity on a public hospital site should be offered a “contract change payment” to move to the new Sláintecare Consultant Contract;
• Introduce a scheme to allow a special derogation from pay caps to address recruitment to highly specialised posts;
• The Department of Health should ensure that HIQA’s quality and safety regulatory functions are extended to all healthcare settings;
• Comprehensive data should be collected on the nature and scale of activity in the private hospital system equivalent to those collected in the public system;
• Implement the agreed monitoring and reporting system to robustly monitor and enforce the existing consultant contract.

Fórsa backs vaccination initiative
by Diarmaid Mac a Bhaird
 

A new alliance aimed at improving vaccination rates and reducing vaccine hesitancy has been launched by health minister Simon Harris.


A new alliance aimed at improving vaccination rates and reducing vaccine hesitancy has been launched by health minister Simon Harris. The Vaccine Alliance, which hopes to encourage greater uptake of childhood vaccines, will be comprised of healthcare professionals, policy makers, patient advocates, students and people from groups most affected by vaccine hesitancy.

 

Launching the initiative, Harris challenged social media platforms to decide “which side they are on” in the vaccine debate. He said they should consider closing accounts and web pages that spread false information about the so-called ‘dangers’ of vaccinations.

 

“These platforms can be a powerful tool for good, or they can be a vehicle for falsehoods and lies, and they need to decide what side they want to be on,” he said.

 

There were roughly 1,000 additional cases of mumps this year compared to last, and more than 50 cases of measles. “It shows the need for this alliance to push back against vaccine hesitancy,” said Harris.

 

On the positive side, a concerted public campaign based on evidence-based information has pushed HPV vaccine rates up from 51% to 70% in a short period of time.

 

Fórsa’s head of communications Bernard Harbor welcomed the move as an important public health initiative. “The establishment of the alliance will help boost the uptake of childhood vaccination, an essential public health measure that has been undermined by reckless misinformation in recent times,” he said.

Pay clash in prospect
by Bernard Harbor
 

Fórsa’s new general secretary has expressed frustration at the Government’s handling of the Public Service Stability Agreement (PSSA), and says there is a risk of the agreement unravelling unless there is urgent action to address its weaknesses.


Fórsa’s new general secretary has expressed frustration at the Government’s handling of the Public Service Stability Agreement (PSSA), and says there is a risk of the agreement unravelling unless there is urgent action to address its weaknesses.

 

Kevin Callinan, who took over as general secretary of the 80,000-strong union in July, said problems he had raised in March had yet to be resolved. This despite informal talks with senior officials in the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform (DPER) over recent weeks.

 

He said the PSSA, which delivered a fourth pay adjustment of 1.75% this month was coming under pressure.

 

Kevin said a process for addressing profession-specific and grade-specific pay issues across the civil and public service should be put in place quickly. He called for this to be done with a view to reaching agreement in each area by the end of next March, so that talks on a successor to the PSSA could deal with the outcomes.

 

The PSSA is due to conclude at the end of 2020, which means negotiations would have to begin in the middle of next year in time for any proposed successor to be put to ballots of the various unions’ members.

 

Kevin said Fórsa’s Consultative Council, which is made up of representatives of all the union’s branches, would meet next month to consider developments.

 

“If there is still no progress at that stage, I envisage the union authorising the preparation of claims for the various grades, groups and categories, and developing an industrial strategy to progress them.

 

“We would be in an untenable situation if the instability around the PSSA continues to drift – one that would demand a significant shift in Fórsa’s emphasis, with potentially serious implications for the future of the agreement,” he said.

Women’s pensions 35% lower than men’s
by Diarmaid Mac a Bhaird
 

Women's pensions are up to 35% lower than those of retired men, according to research from the Economic and Social Research Institute (ESRI).


Women's pensions are up to 35% lower than those of retired men, according to research from the Economic and Social Research Institute (ESRI).

 

Its new report, Gender, Pensions and Income in Retirement, found that 55% of retired men have a private or occupational pension, compared to just 28% of women.

 

And it says the gender pension gap is also fuelled by the fact that, on average, women spend less time in the workforce than men.

 

The report recommends a range of policies to improve female pension coverage and encourage more continuity in employment.

 

Fórsa official Billy Hannigan said the report was an important contribution to the discussion on pension reform. “It underlines the need for auto-enrolment so that occupational pensions are open to all workers. Better child and elder care supports are also needed to address the gender pension gap,” he said.

 

Mr Hannigan added it was important to highlight the effect that taking time off work has on pension entitlements. “This has implications for women’s private and occupational pensions, and their service duration in terms of entitlements for public and State pensions.”

 

The report also noted that women with higher educational attainments were less likely to be effected by the gender pension gap.

 

Further information is available HERE and the full report can be found HERE.

Fórsa backs climate demonstrations
by Bernard Harbor
 

Fórsa is urging its members to support the ‘global climate strike,’ an international protest in support of action on climate change that’s planned for Friday 20th September.


Fórsa is urging its members to support the ‘global climate strike,’ an international protest in support of action on climate change that’s planned for Friday 20th September.

 

The initiative, spearheaded by the Irish and international students behind recent school strikes for climate action, will involve demonstrations and other initiatives around the country in what the organisers expect to be the largest ever worldwide mobilisation for action on the climate crisis.

 

The union is urging members to support major lunchtime protests in Cork and Dublin (details below) or, where possible, to take leave to travel to attend. There are also events planned for over 60 towns in ten counties across the country. You can find your closest local event using this live map.

 

If there’s no event currently planned in your local area, you can sign up to create your own one HERE. A team of volunteers is available to help people organise an event, and you can contact Fórsa campaigns director Joe O’Connor to access this support.

 

“We are encouraging members to join in one of the demonstrations around the country during their lunch break. We’re also encouraging those who can’t get to a demonstration to organise an action in their workplace. This could be a meeting, a stand, a workplace photo for use on social media or an approach to management,” said Joe.

 

Although they use the word ‘strike’ to describe the day of action, the organisers explicitly acknowledge that many workers are not able to take formal strike action for legal or other reasons. This is the situation in Ireland, where the law precludes industrial action unless it relates to a ‘trade dispute’ between an employer and its employees.

 

Fórsa has responded to the organisers’ call for workers in such circumstances to add their voice to the demand for climate action in other ways.

 

Dublin demonstration: Assemble at the Fórsa banner in Merrion Square at 1pm. If you are able, you can join the march at 12 noon at the Custom House and march to Merrion Square.


Cork demonstration: Assemble at the Fórsa banner at 12pm at the bottom of Grand Parade.


You can find your closest local event using this live map.

 

Contact Joe O’Connor for information or assistance from Fórsa.

 

Get more information on the Global Climate Strike HERE.

Four-day week campaign planned
by Bernard Harbor
 

Fórsa is to play a lead role in the Irish leg of an international campaign for a four-day working week, which will be launched in Dublin later this month.


Fórsa is to play a lead role in the Irish leg of an international campaign for a four-day working week, which will be launched in Dublin later this month. The launch event will feature contributions from Irish and New Zealand-based employers who have successfully implemented four-day working arrangements for their staff.

 

The campaign will outline the economic, societal, environmental, personal and other benefits that could arise from the adoption of shorter working time, in all sectors of the economy, in the context of technological change and new forms of work organisation.

 

The Dublin launch will include contributions from Fórsa general secretary Kevin Callinan, Friends of the Earth, and the National Women’s Council of Ireland. Aileen O’Carroll of Maynooth University will also present a report on the issue.

 

But the highlight of the day is likely to be Andrew Barnes, founder of New Zealand financial advice company Perpetual Guardian, which won international acclaim when it introduced a four-day week for its 250 staff last year. The Galway-based company ICE, which has also successfully introduced a four-day week, will also contribute.

Also in this issue
Refugee settlement partners sought
by Róisín McKane
 

Fórsa is asking union branches and members to get involved in a fresh approach to resettling refugee families in communities across Ireland. The union is backing a new ‘community sponsorship’ initiative, which helps local communities to take responsibility for giving financial and other supports to refugee families from war-torn areas.


Community Sponsorship Ireland brings together a number of organisations including the Irish Red Cross, the Refugee Council, the UN Refugee Agency, Amnesty International, University College Dublin and the migrant and refugee centre NASC. Fórsa is now a member of its advisory board.


The union is seeking expressions of interest from branches and individual members who are interested in getting involved in the initiative. Its campaigns director Joe O’Connor hopes that a number of members, and at least one branch, will be willing to take part in a pilot phase by the end of this year.


Community sponsorship is an alternative to the traditional state-centred model of refugee placement. Its community-based approach helps refugee families to access social and professional networks in their new host communities, and introduces them to local state services, amenities, education and language resources.


Joe said the partnership offered a positive opportunity to make a lasting difference to people’s lives.


“Fórsa’s presence in communities across the country, our links with other organisations, and the breadth of knowledge, skills and occupations within our membership makes us a perfect organisation to make a contribution to the success of community sponsorship in Ireland,” he said.


For more information on Fórsa’s partnership, or to express an interest in getting involved, please contact joconnor@forsa.ie. Get more information on the programme HERE.

Employers’ responsibilities on disability clarified
by Diarmaid Mac a Bhaird
 

The Supreme Court has confirmed that employers have a duty to provide ‘reasonable accommodation’ for employees with a disability. In other words, they must make reasonable adjustments to the workplace, work organisation or equipment to ensure that staff members with disabilities can continue to work.

 

Fórsa welcomed the ruling, in which the Supreme Court set aside the decision of the Court of Appeal in a specific case, and referred it back to the Labour Court for determination.

 

The court also provided clarification on how the law in relation to reasonable accommodation should be applied, saying employers’ duty to provide reasonable accommodation should be ascribed a broad ambit.

 

In particular, it said that the primary obligation of an employer is to take appropriate measures, where required, to enable the employee to continue in employment. That duty includes an obligation to consider relieving the employee of duties they cannot perform, with the extent of this being assessed in each case by an adjudication officer with appeal to the Labour Court.

 

The court said that the duty to provide reasonable accommodation does not extend to an obligation to create an entirely new job, but said a reorganised job is not necessarily a new job.

 

It also said a “wise employer” would consult with their employee before making decisions about their future employment, though this was not a legal requirement.

 

It noted that making reasonable accommodation should not impose a disproportionate financial or other burden on the employer, but said this should take account of available State supports.

 

Fórsa official Billy Hannigan said the decision brought clarity to the application of the law. “The fact that the emphasis in any case will be on the individual circumstances of each person is a positive result, and a win for the union and for the rights of people with disabilities in the workplace,” he said.

 

Billy also welcomed Justice Peter Charleton’s statement that it’s not “particularly useful to see disability as medical in nature. A person with a disability remains a person, an individual with human dignity who is required to be treated as such.”

Budget priorities laid out
by Diarmaid Mac a Bhaird
 

A pre-budget submission, calling for increased funding for public services and measures to alleviate the housing crisis has been published by the Irish Congress of Trade Unions (ICTU).

 

The paper, “Building a shared and sustainable future,” recommends greater healthcare and education funding, the establishment of a public affordable housebuilding scheme, greater investment in a just climate transition, and the establishment of a Brexit adjustment fund.

 

It argues that increased public spending is necessary to enhance infrastructure, while warning that tax cuts could result in overheating and harm the economy in the long-run.

 

It also suggests several progressive measures to raise revenue and fund greater public service investment. These include raising employers PSRI on incomes over €100,000, reforms to capital accusation tax, a higher excise tax on diesel, and a new tax on single use plastics.

 

The paper cites a number of risks to the Irish economy including Brexit, the climate crisis, precarious work and inequality and the housing and homelessness emergencies.

 

Other recommended measures include addressing Ireland’s two-tier health system, enhancements to planned pension reforms, and a greater policy emphases on Irish small and medium businesses, rather than US multinationals.

 

Read the submission HERE.

Daft advertising outcome welcomed
by Niall Shanahan
 

Fórsa has welcomed a Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) adjudication, which found that rental adverts on the property website daft.ie were discriminatory. The WRC said the ads discriminated on the grounds of housing status, age and family status.


The decision, which follows a three-year legal action by the Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission (IHREC), has likely implications for other Irish platforms hosting discriminatory content.


The case, which was taken under the Equal Status Act, concerned adverts that featured terms like “rent allowance not accepted,” “suit family or professionals only,” “would suit young professionals,” and “references required.”


Fórsa equality officer Andy Pike said the decision vindicated the rights of prospective tenants.


“We are especially pleased to note the inclusion of a prohibition on adverts stating that prospective tenants on rent supplement or other benefits will not be accepted by landlords. This highlights the risks faced by those on low incomes who may be at more risk of homelessness because of landlords’ discrimination,” he said.


The full text of the decision is available HERE.

Congress issues Brexit warning
by Diarmaid Mac a Bhaird
 

An adjustment fund and a retraining programme for workers likely to be affected by Brexit are needed to minimise the potential damage of a no-deal Brexit, according to a new report by the Irish Congress of Trade Unions (ICTU).

 

Preparing for Brexit: ICTU proposals to support jobs and workers also recommend establishing a short-time work scheme to preserve jobs, and a Brexit adjustment assistance fund to upskill and retrain at-risk workers. It also says the European Globalisation Adjustment Fund must be able to support workers made redundant on foot of Brexit.

 

Meanwhile, British unions that represent healthcare workers have warned of disruption to supplies of medicine, particularly drugs for cancer diagnosis and therapies that can’t be stockpiled.

 

The unions say Brexit poses threats to workers and patients in the UK’s National Health Service (NHS), and that a no-deal exit would likely effect funding for under-pressure services. They also fear that EU nationals working in the NHS could be left in limbo.

 

In a separate development, staff and representatives of both Fórsa and Siptu took part in a demonstration outside the British embassy in Dublin last week. Organised by Britons living in Ireland, the protest was against the proroguing of the Westminster parliament and the implications of a no-deal Brexit for Britain and Ireland.

 

You can find more on ICTU’s Brexit report HERE, and more on the TUC health unions’ statement HERE.

New campaign targets hate crime
by Hazel Gavigan
 

A new campaign for the introduction of hate crime legislation in Ireland has been launched by the European Network Against Racism Ireland (ENAR), of which Fórsa is a member.


The ‘love not hate’ initiative will petition the Government to introduce hate crime legislation, while encouraging people to report racist and other hate-fuelled attacks. Its petition has already gained over 8,000 signatures.


Ireland is currently one of the few European Union countries not to have any form of legislation to address hate crime, which is usually defined as a crime, typically involving violence, which is motivated by prejudice on the basis of race, religion, sexual orientation, or other grounds.

 

Fórsa equality officer Billy Hannigan remarked on the timeliness of the initiative.


“It’s very appropriate in the current climate of increased racially-fuelled hate attacks in Ireland that this campaign is gaining momentum. The union is proud to support ‘love not hate’ and we hope members will not only sign the petition, but also publicise the campaign online and in their workplace,” he said.


Click HERE to sign the petition and HERE for more information on the campaign.

A date for diaries
by Bernard Harbor
 

The Fórsa global solidarity conference is scheduled to take place in the union’s Nerney’s Court office in Dublin on the evening of Friday 15th and Saturday 16th November.

 

The event will feature top speakers on issues like Brexit, climate change and solidarity with Columbia and Palestine.

The event will be a mixture of guest speakers, panel discussions and debates. Further details, including information about registration, will issue soon.